Skip to main content

Nightmare Alley (2021)


Nightmare Alley is a 2021 American neo-noir psychological thriller film directed by Guillermo del Toro from a screenplay by del Toro and Kim Morgan, based on the 1946 novel of the same name by William Lindsay Gresham, being the second feature film adaptation of Gresham's novel, following the 1947 version. The film received positive reviews from critics but flopped at the box office, grossing a total of $39 million worldwide against a $60 million production budget. It received four nominations at the 94th Academy Awards, including Best Picture.

A grifter working his way up from low-ranking carnival worker to lauded psychic medium matches wits with a psychiatrist bent on exposing him.

Freddy and Krasnaya Movie Review
***SPOILER ALERT***

K: Before starting my review, I found out that Nightmare Alley is the second film adaptation of the novel of the same name by William Linzey Gresham. First Nightmare Alley is a 1947 American film noir directed by Edmund Goulding. I am willing to check it out later. Guillermo Del Toro knows how to create pressure. He is a master at creating an atmosphere. Every scene is accurately calibrated, with spectacular work with light, throwing a noir shadow on Nightmare Alley, with clearly drawn lines and catchy, colourful elements like that of the Enoch creature that killed his mother, or the red lipstick of Lilith Ritter (Cate Blanchett). It was an aesthetic pleasure for me for two and a half hours.

F: Hiya Krasnaya! I didn't know that. We're definitely going to check out that older version here at Cine It in the future, since I've loved this movie so much. Finally, something really entertaining. I agree with you. I was mesmerized by the neo-noir atmosphere; it's just beautifully detailed. This movie can start a little slow, but oh boy, like a good book, once you get hooked, there's no stopping. I'm a big fan of Guillermo Del Toro and we need to dedicate a themed week to him here. I have to admit that I wouldn't be able to tell if this was a Guillhermo Del Toro movie, if I had to guess.

Enoch - The killer baby
Reminds me of that time when me and Krasnaya visited Kunstkamera.
K: Yes, the story grabs your attention and the film, like a river, flows and flows from small to full-flowing rapids. And the topic, in general, is quite intriguing. Behind the scenes of fakirs and magicians. The cast is extraordinary! Bradley Cooper, Cate Blanchett, Willem Dafoe, Toni Collette, etc. All of them did a good job, although sometimes I caught myself thinking that Bradley Cooper was a bit woody and lacking in emotions, especially at the beginning of the film. Cate Blanchett was exceptional! She is always mysterious, beautiful, and dangerous at the same time.

F: I thought that the cast was genius. I liked every single character in this movie. I think Bradley Cooper shined in that last scene. I'm starting to like this guy a lot, even if it's hard to forgive him for that goddamn movie with Lady Gaga. Yuck! Cleaning up the last phrase for good, we have: Cate Blanchett and her art deco consulting office. GLORIOUS! I was also quite excited by the many subjects in the movie; spiritualism and charlatanism, power and psychology. What makes you feel more powerful? Reading people and being able to manipulate them, or being stinking rich?

Femme Fatale Cate Blanchett
Femme fatale
K: The morality of the film is clear as day. So the ending turned out to be correct in terms of dramaturgy. I actually knew that Stan was going to be the next geek - a human or a beast, when he jumped on the wagon full of chickens. The only thing I wasn't able to answer was why the main character was driven by a thirst for power and profit so much? Do you know the answer Freddy?

F: Free will, I guess. He just chose that path. Pete (David Strathairn) warns him about pursuing the power inside that little black book. Zeena (Toni Collette) also warned him with the readings from her Tarot cards. He didn't listen, got blinded by power and greed, and ended up flying too close to the sun. I also think he ended up not having faith in anything; this was aggravated by his career choice perhaps. He didn't care if he did something wrong, and you can see this in many different scenes to different degrees. By the way, I love how the story still leaves us a door open to the world of mysticism with that Tarot reading. There's a lot we don't know about Stan also. Why did he hate his father so much? We get a hint that he was probably abused by the man with whom his mother cheated. Did he blame that on his father? We really need to watch that 40's version to get some details off! Also, I didn't quite get what the connection was with that little jar baby, Enoch. Is it just the parricide issue or is there something more?

Bradley Cooper Insane laugh
F: This is our third movie for this week's theme and we both highly recommend it. Go watch it and have fun!

Freddy's Score: 90/100
Krasnaya's Score: 80/100

FINAL SCORE

DEL TORO ON JIMMY KIMMEL

COOPER AND DEL TORO MOVIE SCENE BREAK DOWN

BEHIND THE SCENES

Comments

🎬 Join the CineIt Movie Club!

Get exclusive reviews and recommendations delivered straight to your inbox. Never miss a great movie again!

🍿

Support CineIt

Enjoy my rants?
Help keep the popcorn flowing!

Buy Me Some Popcorn

Popular posts from this blog

Sonatine (1993)

Sonatine is a 1993 Japanese yakuza film directed, written and edited by Takeshi Kitano, who also stars in the film. It won numerous awards and became one of Kitano's most successful and praised films, garnering him a sizable international fan base. The title Sonatine comes from the musical term sonatina. Kitano said that when learning the piano, when the learner gets to sonatinas they have to decide where they want to go, whether it is to classical, jazz or popular music; marking the point of crucial decision making. This refers to the character Murakawa in the film. source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_Return Several yakuza from Tokyo are sent to Okinawa to help end a gang war. The war then escalates and the Tokyo drifters decide to lay low at the beach. source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0108188/ ***SPOILER ALERT*** K: So, the list of Kitano films we watched continues to grow. This time we had an absolutely amazing picture - Sona...

Kpop Demon Hunters (2025)

Plot Summary: Three talented young K-pop trainees discover they have supernatural abilities to battle ancient demons lurking in modern-day Korea. They must balance their demanding training for a much-anticipated debut with their secret mission to protect the world. Directors: Maggie Kang, Chris Appelhans Screenplay: Danya Jimenez, Hannah McMechan, Maggie Kang, Chris Appelhans Producer: Michelle Wong Music: Marcelo Zarvos Starring: Arden Cho as Rumi May Hong as Mira Ji-young Yoo as Zoey Ahn Hyo-seop as Jinu Yunjin Kim as Celine Ken Jeong as Bobby Lee Byung-hun as Gwi-Ma   ***SPOILER ALERT*** Peer Pressure & Pleasant Surprises My daughter came home from school the other day looking like she'd been left out of the cool kids' club because she was the only one who hadn't seen Kpop Demon Hunters. I knew right then my Satur...

Gunslingers (2025)

Plot Summary: In 1903 New York, a former gunslinger who has sworn off violence gets pulled back into a world of crime and betrayal when family secrets and old enemies resurface. Director: Brian Skiba Screenplay: Brian Skiba Producers: Randall Batinkoff, Brian Skiba, Laurie Love, Scott Reed Cinematography: Patrice Lucien Cochet Music: Richard Patrick Starring: Nicolas Cage as Ben Stephen Dorff as Thomas Keller Heather Graham as Val Scarlet Rose Stallone as Bella Tzi Ma as Lin Jeremy Kent Jackson as Robert Keller Costas Mandylor as Jericho   ***SPOILER ALERT*** An AI-Generated Mess The first thing that hits you when Gunslingers starts is an AI slop rendition of New York in 1903. Oh boy, I thought, we're off to a great start. The film then throws this bizarre mix at you: amateur-looking shots that seem filmed on a smar...

La Mante (2017)

Plot Summary: Twenty-five years after being imprisoned, Jeanne Deber, a notorious serial killer known as "The Mantis," offers to help the police catch a copycat killer, but only if she can work with her estranged son, who is now a police officer. Director: Alexandre Laurent Writers: Alice Chegaray-Breugnot, Nicolas Jean, GrΓ©goire Demaison, Laurent Vivier Music: FranΓ§ois Lietout Starring: Carole Bouquet as Jeanne Deber / The Mantis Fred Testot as Damien Carrot Jaques Weber as Charles Carrot Pascal Demolon as Dominique Feracci Manon Azem as Lucie Carrot Serge Riaboukine as Crozet Robinson Stevenin as Alex Crozet FredΓ©rique Bel as Virginie Delorme Jump to the Plot Explained Section   ***SPOILER ALERT*** A Boring, Wannabe Hannibal Lecter This is officially the first TV series review I'm doing here at Cine It. I'm no...

Cinanima Festival - 9th November

My Last Day at Cinanima (With Eva) For my second and, ridiculously, last day (lol) in Espinho for the 49ΒΊ Cinanima Festival, I took my daughter Eva to the Family Screening. This one was called "Mini Micro," a selection of short animations put together by Casa de AnimaΓ§Γ£o, held on November 9th at the Centro Multimeios. I'm gutted that I couldn't stay for the whole week... 😞 I really wanted to see the international and national competition screenings. But for now, I'm just doing my own little competition here at Cine It. πŸ˜› So, here's the full list of the shorts we saw, ranked from my favorite to my least favorite. πŸ“… A Quick Note By the time I'm posting this, the festival is still running (it ends on November 23rd). If you're anywhere near Espinho, make sure you catch it. It's seriously worth the visit. πŸ₯‡ Cine It Gold: Tiger (2010) In first place, no contest, is Tiger (or Tige...

The Bad Guys 2 (2025)

Plot Summary: The Bad Guys are struggling to find trust and acceptance in their newly minted lives as Good Guys, when they are pulled out of retirement and forced to do "one last job" by an all-female squad of criminals. Director: Pierre Perifel Screenplay: Yoni Brenner, Etan Cohen Based on: The Bad Guys by Aaron Blabey Edited by: Jesse Averna Music: Daniel Pemberton Produced by: Damon Ross Starring: Sam Rockwell as Mr. Wolf Marc Maron as Mr. Snake Awkwafina as Ms. Tarantula / "Webs" Craig Robinson as Mr. Shark Anthony Ramos as Mr. Piranha Zazie Beetz as Diane Foxington / Crimson Paw Danielle Brooks as Kitty Kat Natasha Lyonne as Doom / "Susan" Maria Bakalova as Pigtail Petrova Alex Borstein as Misty Luggins Richard Ayoade as Professor Marmalade   ⚠️ SPOILER ALERT ⚠️ ...